Giftster alternatives for sharing wishlists
Giftster does what it does well — a group-based family wishlist with hidden purchases. An alternative usually isn't about it being wrong, just about wanting a different shape.
7 min readUpdated September 1, 2026
In short
- Giftster's group-based model with hidden purchases works well for many families as-is
- Consider an alternative for a single-link sharing model instead of a group to join
- Twish, GoWish, Wisher and Things To Get Me let guests reserve with no account
- Twish, GoWish, Wisher, Things To Get Me and MyRegistry all support items from any store
- Twish and GoWish hide reservations from the list owner with no reveal option
What people are usually looking for
Nobody switches wishlist apps at random — it's almost always one specific thing. Common reasons include:
- A simpler guest experience, with less setup before someone can just look and reserve.
- A different sharing model — a single link rather than a group you join.
- Support for pasting a product link from any store, rather than a specific import tool.
- A different interface or visual style.
- A different reservation behaviour, or how long it stays hidden from the list owner.
- Family or group functionality that fits a specific household differently.
- Fewer account requirements for people who just want to view one list.
Twish
Twish shares a single wishlist as one link rather than through a group you join, so a guest opens it directly instead of navigating a shared family space. Paste a product link from almost any store and Twish fills in the title, image and price. Reservations stay permanently hidden from the wishlist owner — there's no later reveal option — and guests reserve with just an email, no account required. Free during the current MVP.
Elfster
Elfster is built primarily around Secret Santa and gift-exchange organising, with wishlists that support that structure — automated name draws, group messaging, support for large groups. It's free, ad-supported. It suits a different use case than a general household wishlist: a specific gift exchange rather than an everyday personal list.
MyRegistry
MyRegistry is a free, universal registry platform with a one-click browser extension for adding items from almost any retailer, but it's built mainly for wedding and baby-shower registries rather than recurring family or personal wishlists.
Wisher (Wishr)
A free wishlist app with a browser extension for any store, price-drop tracking, and an AI gift-finder. Reservations stay hidden from the list owner until after the occasion, and guests can reserve without creating an account.
GoWish
A mobile-first wishlist app with no restriction on which store items come from, sharing via SMS, WhatsApp, email and similar apps, and a reservation system that hides claims from the list owner while keeping them visible to other guests. It's grown quickly, past 13.6 million registered users, and includes a discovery feed of gift ideas.
Things To Get Me
A free, privacy-first option that requires no signup at all — lists work through unique, unguessable links, and a browser plugin adds items from any site. Guests tick off what they're getting; the owner can't see who ticked what unless they later open a separate "Reveal" section, which can also be disabled entirely.
Amazon Lists
Amazon's own lists support Private, Shared and Public visibility with a "Don't spoil my surprises" default that hides purchases from the owner for a period. Since March 2023, they no longer support items from outside Amazon, so they only fit if your gifting is genuinely Amazon-centric.
Is there a reason to leave Giftster specifically?
Not inherently — Giftster's group model and hidden-purchase system work well for many families. An alternative makes sense if you specifically want a single-link sharing model instead of a group, or products added from any store without a dedicated import tool.
One list. One link. No group to join.
Frequently asked questions
More gift ideas
Best wishlist apps: what to look for
What each major wishlist app actually does, fact-checked — not a ranked "best" list.
9 min read
Amazon Wishlist alternatives for gifts from more than one store
For when what you actually want isn't all sold by one retailer.
7 min read
How to avoid duplicate gifts without ruining the surprise
Two people, one gift, no coordination required — here's what actually prevents duplicates.
5 min read